Saulawa, Mahmud Abdullahi, Umaru, Ghali Abaka, Ayobami, Dorcas, Ibrahim, Kabir, Akawu, Bala: Prevalence of dog bite cases in humans and vaccination coverage against rabies in selected parts of Lagos State, Nigeria
ABSTRACT
Aim:
Lagos State has a long history of rabies control efforts. However, the success of such efforts and the goal to eliminate rabies is yet to be realized. This study was carried out to evaluate dog bite cases in humans presented to the Lagos State Teaching Hospital Ikeja and to evaluate anti-rabies vaccination coverage in dogs presented for dog consultation at the State Animal Hospital Agege and a private Veterinary Clinic Ikeja between the years of 2012 to 2018.
Methods:
Factors such as age, sex, and season of dog bites in humans as well as the age and sex of dogs presented for anti-rabies vaccination were obtained for the years under review. Also, a cross-sectional survey was conducted using structured questionnaires to assess knowledge of rabies and factors affecting routine anti-rabies dog vaccination amongst consenting residents and dog owners of selected households in Ikeja and Agege local government areas of Lagos state.
Results:
From the retrospective data on dog bites in humans, a total of 347 dog bites were reported with 59.7% (207) occurring in females and 40.3% (140) in males, all of whom were adults aged between 25 and 40 years. Seasonal distribution of bites indicates a higher frequency in the months of April, July, and October. A total of 300 (13.2%) dogs were vaccinated out of 2,275 cases presented to the State Animal Hospital Agege, 48% (144) of which were females and 52% (156) males. 62.7% (188) of the dogs were aged between 3 and 12 months, 23.3% (70) were aged between 12 and 36 months, and 14% (42) were aged above 36 months. A total of 295 (28.1%) dogs were vaccinated out of the 1,048 cases presented to the private Veterinary Clinic at Ikeja. In the cross-sectional study, 422 consenting households were issued a questionnaire across the two local government areas. Overall, 330 (78.2%) had satisfactory knowledge on rabies, while 92 (21.8%) had a non-satisfactory knowledge on rabies, 287 (68%) knew what to do when bitten by a dog, while 135 (32%) gave a non-satisfactory response, 302 (71.6%) had reasonable response to perceived threats of rabies whereas 120 (28.4%) respondents were not quite knowledgeable on the perceived threats of rabies. Factors affecting routine anti-rabies vaccination in dogs such as breed, cost, distance, and ease of handling were assessed among 196 dog owners out of the 422 selected households, with no statistical significance as factors associated with or affecting dog rabies vaccination coverage.
Conclusions:
The result of this study indicates that dog bites as a threat to the spread of rabies is still a menace and anti-rabies vaccination coverage of dogs falls below the recommended standard by the World Health Organization despite various existing control programs. Despite the majority of respondents having satisfactory knowledge on rabies, their attitudes towards rabies prevention were inadequate.
KEYWORDS Dog bites; humans; prevalence; rabies; vaccination; Nigeria
Introduction
The word rabies originates from the Latin word Rabere which means to rage or rave, and may or lytta, which means frenzy or madness. Rabies, a vaccine-preventable zoonotic viral disease, is a neglected tropical disease characterized by acute progressive encephalitis and is always fatal once signs and symptoms appear [ 1]. It is an extensively distributed viral zoonotic disease of major public health importance that affects humans and domestic and wild animals. Rabies is well known by the Nigerians based on the availability of various indigenous terms that the disease had been recognized in Nigeria including ciwon kare (Hausa), ara nikita (Igbo), and digbolugi (Yoruba) [ 2]. Dog is the principal reservoir that maintains and transmits the disease to other animals and man in Nigeria [ 3– 7] from which an estimated 21,500 deaths occur in West and Central Africa [ 8]. The disease infects domestic and wild animals and is spread to people via infected saliva through bites, licking, or scratches [ 9]. Once symptoms develop, rabies is nearly always fatal [ 10]. Dogs are the source of 98% of human rabies deaths [ 10]. The occurrence of rabies in humans and domestic animals is well known, but the role that wild mammals play in its spread has not been determined [ 11]. Transmission of rabies to humans can be greatly reduced by health awareness and change of behavior towards the disease. Vaccination against rabies virus is a highly effective method of preventing rabies in humans and animals. Few countries (e.g., Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and The British Isles) are free of the disease due to successful eradication programs or their island status and enforcement of rigorous quarantine regulations [ 12]. It remains a disease with no cure and the survival of affected humans and animals is extremely rare [ 13]. Of concern also is that 40% of dog bite victims are children under 15 years of age who may not report minor scratches or dog bites to their caregivers and in cases where the offending dog is rabid the possibility of rabies infection resulting increases [ 14]. Children as a result of their curiosity, limited knowledge, and limited experience about dog behavior and most importantly inability to protect themselves from attacks from dogs may be partly responsible for the higher number of bites in the pediatric population [ 14]. Furthermore, children are more likely to suffer multiple bites including bites to the face and head that have high innervations with a higher propensity to contraction of rabies infection [ 15]. Most of the cases of dog bites were by stray dogs that attacked their victims aggressively without being provoked. Dog bites in humans are of public health importance globally, as 35%–50% of victims of rabid dog bites may contract rabies if adequate and timely pre and/or post-exposure prophylaxes are not administered [ 16]. In many countries of those continents, few activities are underway to prevent rabies occurrence in humans and to control rabies in dogs, even with the high death rates in humans resulting from rabies. Dog licensing, killing of stray dogs, muzzling, and other measures contributed to the elimination of rabies from the United Kingdom in the early 20th century. More recently, routine expansive vaccination of cats, dogs, and ferrets has been successful in combating rabies in many developed countries. Several cases of human rabies survivors were reported and documented in various studies, some of them include; in Texas, USA, a 17-year-old lady survived rabies exposure due to bats [ 17]; also in 2011, an 8-year-old girl survived rabies exposure due to cats at California, USA [ 18], and a 13-year-old girl also survived a rabid dog attack in India in 2011 [ 19], and these success were achieved due to different level of critical care and support given to the patients, but human rabies remains almost always fatal. Most of the cases of rabies in the present studies were from rural areas where poverty, ignorance, and poor dog ownership culture abound. Results from a study showed that the majority of the dogs involved in bites were poorly vaccinated or unvaccinated for rabies. Such low vaccination rates in dogs as in a similar study in Nigeria [ 20] are of serious public health concern as they mitigate against effective control of rabies in Nigeria compared to the most developed world where mass vaccination of domestic dogs has successfully eliminated or controlled domestic dog rabies. Almost all human deaths caused by rabies occur in Asia and Africa. It is estimated that about 60,000 human rabies deaths occur yearly following an encounter with rabid dogs. Developing countries with a large number of dogs, most of which movement is not restricted, account for approximately 98% of human rabies. The first documentation of rabies in Nigeria in humans was in 1912 and dogs in 1925 [ 21] and since then many authors [ 11, 22– 25] have established that the disease is endemic in the country with more recent reports showing that the prevalence of the disease is on the increase. Under reporting of rabies in endemic developing countries has resulted in the disease being ignored by medical professionals and subsequently poor assistance from the international community and donor agencies [ 26]. Therefore, information on vaccination and perception of rabies by the residents of selected local government areas (Agege and Ikeja) has the benefit of enabling the health agencies to better evaluate and plan for a more efficient and effective rabies control program. The overall objective of this study was to evaluate the situation of rabies and compliance with anti-rabies vaccination as a control program among humans and animals in the study area.
Materials and Methods
Study area
The study was carried out in two local government areas of Lagos State namely Agege and Ikeja local government areas between June 2019 and August 2019. Agege is a suburb and one of the local government areas in the metropolitan area of Lagos State with coordinates 6.6180ºN, 3.3209ºE and covers an area of approximately 17.0km²—Density: 37,406/km² with a population of about 459,939. The inhabitants of Agege are multi-ethnic, essentially Yorubas with the presence of a sparse population of non-Yoruba-speaking people ( Fig. 1). Ikeja, the capital of Lagos state is also a local government area in the metropolitan area of Lagos state with coordinates 6.60ºN 3.35ºE, a land area of 49.92 km² (19.27 sq mi), and an elevation of 39 m (128 ft) ( Fig. 1). It has a population of 861,300 and a density of 17,254/km² (44,690/sq mi) and comprises 12 districts with a tropical wet and dry climate (Aw). These local government areas are served by a State Veterinary Hospital in Agege and the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital located at Ikeja as well as several private hospitals.
Figure 1.
Map of Lagos State showing the study areas (Agege and Ikeja local government areas).
Study design
Retrospective data of patient records in the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital Ikeja, State Animal Hospital Agege, and two private veterinary clinics at Ikeja were collated and compiled for seven years (2012–2018). Then, a cross-sectional survey was conducted across the two local government areas to extract information on “Knowledge of rabies and factors affecting anti-rabies vaccination in dogs” among consented residents of Agege and Ikeja.
Sample size determination
The sample size for the cross-sectional survey was determined according to Dohoo et al. [ 26].
n=Zα²pq/ L²
where n is the required sample size, Zα=1.96, the normal deviate at a 5% level of significance,
p=estimate of prevalence, q=1-p, L=allowable error of estimate, using an estimated prevalence of 50% and setting L at 5%, A 10% no response was used for this study. The sample size required in the study was: n=1.96² × 0.5 × 0.5 / (0.05) ²=422 samples.
Data collection
The Director of Veterinary Services for the State and the Medical Director of the Lagos State Teaching Hospital were visited to seek approval for access to patient records for the retrospective studies. Two private veterinary clinics in Ikeja were also visited for patient records. These clinics and hospitals were purposively selected for the retrospective study. The information collected included the following:
- The human records.
- Total dog bite cases monthly and annually.
- Sexes of dog bite victims.
- Age of dog bite victims.
- Animal records.
- Total number of annual dog consultation.
- Total number of anti-rabies vaccine administered yearly
- Age of dogs
- Sex of dogs
Questionnaires were administered to residents of selected communities to obtain information regarding their knowledge on rabies and factors affecting anti-rabies vaccination among dog owners.
Sampling
Purposive sampling was used in selecting hospitals and clinics for the retrospective study. A modified version of the multistage cluster sampling technique with population proportional to size sampling with replacement that is based on the World Health Organization (WHO) expanded programme on immunization coverage survey technique [ 27– 31] was used for the cross-sectional survey. A determined sample size of 422 households, consisting of 43 clusters and 10 households per cluster to was used for the cross-sectional survey.
Data management and statistical analysis
All the data obtained from the clinic was recorded in a notebook and later entered into the computer using Microsoft Excel and imported into SPSS version 20. The data were analyzed and presented using descriptive statistics.
Results
Dog bites in humans in Agege and Ikeja local government areas, Lagos State
Results from this study showed that a total of 347 dog bite cases were reported to the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH) between January 2012 and December 2018. Year 2012 recorded the highest (75) cases of dog bites within the period under study, while 32 cases were recorded in 2016, which is the lowest number of cases recorded so far during the study.
Time series decomposition using the simple average method showed seasonal variations expressed as a seasonal index. Our findings from the seasonal indexes showed that dog bites were densest during the months of February through to November, peaking in the months of April (114), July (121.1), August (114), and October (117.5). The fewest number of dog bite cases were recorded in January (34.6) and December (83.1) with only 34 reported cases.
Age and sex distribution of dog bite victims in humans in Agege and Ikeja local government areas, Lagos State
The findings of this study showed that all the dog bite victims were between the ages of 25–40 years of age, with females having a higher bite frequency (59.7%) compared to males (40.3%). A higher prevalence (20.7%) of dog bite cases was found in males at the year 2012 and lower (10%) in the year 2016, while a high prevalence (22.2%) in females was observed in the year 2012 and a lower prevalence (8.7%) in the year 2016.
Anti-rabies vaccination coverage of dogs in Agege and Ikeja local government areas, Lagos State
Analysis of annual anti-rabies vaccination in dogs carried out at the State animal hospital Agege showed that out of 2,225 dog consultations carried out at the hospital during the period of review, only 300 dogs received anti-rabies vaccine (ARV) despite ARV being the best control and preventive measure against rabies. The highest rate of anti-rabies vaccinations (20.7%) was administered in 2016 followed by a rapid decline in 2017 (8%) and an increase (15.2%) in 2018. These frequencies are represented in Figure 2.
Figure 2.
Annual distribution of dogs vaccinated against rabies in Agege, Lagos State (Nigeria), from the year 2012-2018.
Annual distribution of vaccinated dogs by age and sex was done to know the category of dogs that were frequently presented to the hospital for anti-rabies vaccination for the period of years under review. Records showed that out of the total 300 vaccinated dogs, 156 (52%) were males and 144 (48%) were female dogs.
Most of the vaccinated dogs were within the age of 3–12 months (62.7%), followed by dogs aged 12–36 months (23.3%) and the least vaccinated were dogs older than 36 months (14%).
At the Ikeja Veterinary Clinic, of the total dog consultation of 1,048, only 295 (28.1%) were presented for anti-rabies vaccination between the period of 2012–2018.
Results of this analysis showed that of the 1,048 dogs presented to the clinic under the period of review, only 295 (28.1%) received anti-rabies vaccination. The years had an undulating pattern of vaccination with the year 2017 having the highest vaccination record which was not the case at the veterinary hospital Agege while 2016 had the lowest vaccination record.
Knowledge of rabies among residents of Agege and Ikeja local government areas, Lagos State
A total of 422 consenting households were issued questionnaires to assess their knowledge on rabies and factors associated with or affecting dog ant-rabies vaccination among dog owners within these households. 78.2% of consenting participants had a satisfactory response to knowledge on rabies, while 21.8% had a non-satisfactory response to knowledge on rabies. 68% of participants knew what to do when bitten by a dog, while 32% had questionable knowledge on the next course of action following a dog bite. 54% had satisfactory knowledge on the frequency of dog anti-rabies vaccination and 46% did not give a satisfactory response to the frequency of anti-rabies vaccination in dogs.
Factors associated with anti-rabies vaccination in dogs among dog owners in Agege and Ikeja local government areas, Lagos State
Overall, dog ownership is common among residents of Ikeja and Agege local government areas. Of the 422 consenting households, 196 (46.4%) were dog owners. 35.2% exotic breed, 39.8% mixed breed and 25% local breed. We collected data on the vaccination status of these dogs and tested for association between breed and vaccination status of dogs with a p-value of 0.0024. Factors such as cost of vaccine and vaccination, distance to a veterinary clinic, breed of dog, and ease of handling their dogs were listed as factors affecting routine dog vaccination. 50.5% (99) of dog owners indicated cost as a factor that affects routine vaccination of their dogs against rabies out of which 58 dog owners had vaccinated their dogs despite the cost while 41 dog owners were yet to. The association between cost and vaccination had a p-value of 0.002. 43.9% (86) of dog owners indicated distance as a factor affecting compliance with routine dog anti-rabies vaccination, of these 86 dog owners, 44 had already vaccinated their dogs while 42 were yet to comply. 110 of dog owners were indifferent on distance being a challenge to routinely vaccinate their dogs. 52% (102) stated ease of handling their dogs as a reason why they do not routinely vaccinate their dogs whereas 48% (94) were indifferent on distance being an inhibiting factor.
Discussion
Dog bites in humans are a major public health problem globally. Millions of people are bitten by dogs annually making dog bites of great concern to people. A total of 347 cases of dog bite were reported to LASUTH between the years of 2012 to 2018 although this may not be an exact representation of dog bite cases as not all cases are reported to the hospital. This number is particularly high when compared to the findings of Hambolu et al. [ 31] in a previous study that reported 196 dog bite cases from 3 senatorial districts in Lagos state. There was a steady decline in reported cases from 75 in 2012 to 32 in 2016; this was followed by an increase to 49 in 2017 and 45 in 2018.Local dogs are in most cases free roaming which increases interaction with humans and the likelihood of dog bites occurring. This study confirms that dog bites at risk of transmitting rabies is still a menace in Lagos State. The frequency of dog bites increased significantly during the rainy season, from March to October the reason of which is not evident. This finding is not in line with the results of similar studies [ 11, 32– 34] which noted that most outbreaks of rabies occurred during the dry season which coincides with the breeding season of dogs in most parts of Nigeria when the aggressive behavioral change of male dogs during mating can contribute to biting. Similarly, nursing bitches are naturally aggressive and can bite humans to protect their newly born puppies. There was high a prevalence of dog bites among young adults in this study (25–40 years). This may be connected to the fact that this demography tends to have more frequent unsupervised contact with dogs as they are adults. This finding is not consistent with other reports [ 10, 33– 36] of children being the major victims of, and more vulnerable to, dog bites. A similar study [ 32] conducted in Lagos demonstrated that the majority of dog bite victims were adults, this is consistent with the findings of this study. The male-female ratio showed a female gender bias in the sex distribution of dog bites victims which could be explained by the physical ability of males to outrun an offending dog or in most cases defend themselves by fighting off offending dogs while most females are usually scared at the sight of dogs and therefore more likely to exhibit inappropriate actions such as screaming and running that incites predatory behavior in dogs putting themselves at a disadvantaged position. This agrees with the findings of Omoke and Chukwueloka [ 37] where females were more affected by dog bites, but does not agree with similar studies in Ogoja [ 32], Sokoto [ 38], and other parts of Africa [ 39] where males are more affected than females. Anti-rabies vaccination coverage for this study was inadequate as the rate was lower than the 70% total vaccination coverage recommended by the WHO [ 31] required to achieve herd immunity, especially in adult dogs to prevent rabies outbreaks. This constitutes a higher risk of rabies transmission to humans and is consistent with the findings of Hambolu et al. [ 31] in a previous study carried out in Lagos State. This low vaccination level indicates that the populace may not be aware of or do not consider the threat dogs pose in the epidemiology of rabies. It also indicates that a large proportion of dog the population in Lagos state is at risk of being infected with the rabies virus. A higher percentage of male dogs (52%) were vaccinated against the female dogs (48%). This sex variation could be a result of male: female ratio dominance. Male dogs are more popular than female dogs as a result of their increased aggression and thus effectiveness as guard dogs and for hunting purposes. This finding agrees with the findings of Isek et al. [ 32]. There was also age variation within the vaccinated dog population. Dogs within the 3–12 months age range had the highest vaccination rates. This may be as a result of consistent advice to vaccinate dogs from 3 months old. These findings are consistent with previous studies [ 32] and are not consistent with studies [ 40] that found that pups less than 3 months were less likely to be vaccinated due to reasons such as a lack of awareness about vaccinations. This study also assessed the knowledge of rabies and factors associated with/affecting rabies vaccination coverage among residents and dog owners of the study area. In regards to rabies awareness, the majority (78.2%) of the respondents had satisfactory knowledge of rabies and knew how to recognize the clinical signs of mostly the furious form of rabies in dogs. This finding is not surprising considering the severity and endemic status of the disease as well as routine awareness programs mostly targeted at dog owners and handlers. This is supported by the finding of similarly high levels of awareness in studies conducted in other places where the disease is also endemic including Sokoto, Nigeria [ 41]. Respondents showed an acceptable knowledge on the perceived threats of rabies and the frequency of anti-rabies vaccination in dogs. The result of this study showed that the attitude of respondents towards the prevention of rabies via routine vaccination of dogs among dog owners was affected by certain factors such as the cost of the vaccine, distance to a veterinary healthcare facility, ease of handling their dogs as well as breed of the dog. Despite cost being a factor, most dog owners still had their dogs vaccinated against rabies; this could be attributed to the keeping purpose of the dog as most dog owners owned exotic and mixed breeds of dogs which are mostly kept for their monetary value in terms of breeding. This finding is not in agreement with a similar study by Isek et al. [ 32] where the majority of the vaccinated dogs were local breeds. Despite the cost of vaccine being a factor as well as distance, it was observed that a higher number of dog owners were still in compliance with the routine vaccination practice for maximum protection and prevention of rabies. This can majorly be attributed to the keeping purpose of dogs as most breeders are required to vaccinate their dogs before they can mate their dogs with other dogs or sell off the resultant puppies.
Conclusion
This study showed that dog bites are still a common occurrence among young adults which could serve as a potential source of the spread of the rabies virus if the bite was from a rabid dog. Despite the implication and severity of reported rabies cases in Nigeria, basic control measures such as vaccinating dogs against the disease are still very inadequate. Although the majority of the respondents in this study were aware of rabies, they had little knowledge on the cause of rabies, forms of rabies, and prevention of the disease. Furthermore, the respondents’ attitude towards rabies prevention practices were non satisfactory. Given that bites from rabid dogs are responsible for over 95% of the annual 59,000 human deaths, sustainable elimination of human deaths due to rabies by 2030, requires reduction of the primary transmission risk (dog bite from rabid dogs), through mass dog vaccination, prompt exposure reporting and improved PEP access for bite victims. Understanding the budgetary implications on the national economy and the commitment required from the governing bodies on a national scale is of paramount importance to establish and sustain effective control and preventive measures.
Rabies risk, coupled with welfare concerns suggests the need for continued advocacy towards legislation prohibiting the dog trade in Nigeria and elsewhere. The high-risk community groups such as children, butchers, and adult males need to be educated on responses to dog bite exposure to reduce the impact of this invariable fatal but preventable disease. Moreover, there is a need for mandatory dog vaccination and the implementation of a national rabies program to attain the WHO recommended vaccination coverage of at least 70%. There is a need to establish rabies diagnostic centers in the country’s six geopolitical zones [ 42]. Local inclusion of dog bite occurrence by disease surveillance and notification officers, with related community surveillance tools, can help in rabies/dog surveillance. In addition, there is a need for investment into pathogen discovery by enhancing laboratory-based surveillance for wildlife rabies, understanding its potential role in Nigeria, and the need for quantitative research to understand the various risk factors for disease perpetuation.
Rabies control programmes should be carried out routinely using communication platforms that speaks to all. Education on dog behaviour, responsible pet ownership, and bite prevention should be made an essential extension of a rabies control programme. Rabies campaign programmes should include education on forms of rabies as most respondents were familiar with just the furious form of rabies. There is a need for private owned veterinary clinics to improve on record keeping especially as it relates to dog bites/rabies. Government and other stakeholders should step up education of the public especially dog owners on rabies prevention, in addition to organizing annual free or subsidized mass dog vaccination campaigns.
Data collection was from referred health centers therefore generalization of findings not feasible. No access to records from some private veterinary hospitals.
This study provides evidence on dog bite being a menace affecting both young adults and children. This study provides feedback on the status of anti-rabies vaccination as a control program. Evidence to support the need for continued investment in rabies control programs to support WHO to end human rabies death by 2030.
Acknowledgments
The research team wishes to express its profound gratitude to all the staff of the State Veterinary Hospital in Agege and Lagos State University Teaching Hospital located at Ikeja as well as several private hospitals sampled.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no competing interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Funding
No funding or grant was received in the course of conducting this research as such it was a self-sponsored study.
References
1. Ahmed TA, Ahmad IA, Muftau O, Ahmed I, Ibrahim A, Jimoh MY et al. Review: prospects of dog rabies elimination in Nigeria by 2030. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, 2023; doi: 10.1111/zph.13084
2. Oduye OO, Aghomo HO. Epidemiology of rabies in Nigeria, In: Kuwert E, Mérieux C, Koprowski H, Bögel K (eds.). Rabies in the Tropics. Springer, Berlin, Germany, vol. 59, pp 2007–13, 1985.
3. Nuru S. Epizootiology of canine rabies and its public health significance in Kano State, Nigeria. Nigerian Vet J 1973; 2:49–54.
4. Ezebuiro ED, Fagbami AH, Anosa VO. A survey of rabies in man and animals in Nigeria. Study commissioned by Federal Livestock Department, Federal Ministry of Agriculture, Lagos, Nigeria, p 144, 1980.
5. Ogunkoya AB, Will AE, Ezeokoli CO. Rabies in Oyo State, Nigeria 1971-1981. Int J Zoonoses 1984; 11(1):84–95.
6. Oboegbulem SI. Rabies in man and animals. Fidelity Publishers, Enugu, Nigeria, vol. 1, pp 11–21, 1994.
7. Okoh AEJ. Dog ecology with reference to surveillance of rabies and characterization of rabies virus isolates in Plateau state, Nigeria. PhD Thesis, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria, 1986.
8. Mbilo C, Coetzer A, Bonfoh B, Angot A, Bebay C, Cassamá B, et al. Dog rabies control in west and Central Africa: a review. Acta Tropica 2021; 1(224):105–59.
9. Idachaba SE, Olaleye S, Chuwukere S, Abechi AS, Ehizibolo DO, Fasina FO, et al. Ten year (19982007) retrospective evaluation of the status of dog rabies in Plateau State, Nigeria. Proceedings 46thAnnual Congress of Nigerian Veterinary Medical Association, Abuja, Nigeria, pp 73–8, 2009.
11. Umoh JU, Belino ED. Rabies in Nigeria: a historical review. Int J Zoonoses 1979; 6(1):41–8.
13. Beran GW. Zoonoses in practice. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 1993; 23(5):1085–97.
14. Tenzin, Dhand NK, Gyeltshen T, Firestone S, Zangmo C, Dema C, et al. Dog bites in humans and estimating human rabies mortality in rabies endemic areas of Bhutan. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2011; 5(11):1–13.
16. Toltzis P. Rabies. In: Kilgeman RM, Jerson HB, Behrman RE, Stanton BF, (eds.). Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics. 18th edition, Elsevier, Saunder, Philadelphia, PA, pp 1423–6, 2008.
17. Holzmann Pazgal G, Wanger A, Degaffe G, Rose C, Heresi G, Amaya R, et al. Presumptive abortive human rabies—Texas, 2009. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2010; 59(7):185–90.
18. Wiedeman J, Plant J, Glaser C, Messenger S, Wadford D, Sheriff H, et al. Recovery of patient from clinical rabies—California, 2011. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2012; 61(4):61–5.
19. Rawat AK, Rao SK. Survival of rabies patient. Indian Pediatr 2011; 48:574.
20. Abubakar SA, Bakari AG. Incidence of dog bite injuries and clinical rabies in a tertiary health care institution: a 10-year retrospective study. Ann Afr Med 2012; 11(2):108–11.
21. Boulger LR, Hardy J. Rabies in Nigeria. West Afr Med J 1960; 9(6):223–4.
22. Thorne, ALC. The problem of rabies in Nigeria. Bull Epizootic Dis Afr 1954; 2:265–7.
23. Fagbemi AH, Anosa VO, Ezebuiro EO. Hospital records of human rabies and antirabies prophylaxis in Nigeria from 1969- 1978. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 1981; 75(6):872–6.
24. Bello M, Lukshi BM, Usman B. A fifteen-year retrospective study of the prevalence of rabies in Bauchi State, Nigeria. Nigerian Vet J 2007; 28(2):18–23.
25. Otolorin GR, Aiyedun JO, Mshelbwala PP, Ameh VO, Dzikwi AA, Dipeolu MA. et al. A review on human deaths associated with rabies in Nigeria. J Vaccine Vaccination 2015; 6(1):262.
26. Dohoo IR, Wayne M, Styhn H. Veterinary epidemiologic research. Vet Epidemiol Res Textbook 2010; 5:85–94.
27. WHO. Immunization Coverage Cluster Survey—Reference Manual. Department of Immunization,Vaccines and Biologicals, Family and Community Health, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 2005b.
28. Henderson RH, Sundaresan T. Cluster sampling to assess immunization coverage: a review of experience with a simplified sampling method. Bulletin World Health Organ 1982; 60(2):253–60.
29. Bennett S, Woods T, Liyanage WM, Smith DL. A simplified general method for cluster sample surveys of health in developing countries. World Health Stat Q 1991; 44(3):98–106.
30. Lemeshow S, Robinson D. Surveys to measure programme coverage and impact: a review of the methodology used by the expanded programme on immunization. World Health Stat Q 1985; 38(1):65–75.
31. Hambolu SE, Dzikwi AA, Kwaga JK, Kazeem HM, Umoh JU, Hambolu DA. Rabies and dog bites cases in Lagos State Nigeria: a prevalence and retrospective studies (20062011). Glob J Health Sci 2013; 6(1):107–14.
32. Isek TI, Umoh JU, Dzikwi AA. A retrospective study of dog bite occurrence and anti-rabies vaccination of dogs in a State Veterinary Hospital in Ogoja, Cross River State, Nigeria. Vet Ital 2019; 55(2):163–8.
33. Owai PU. A study of rabies in dogs in Calabar, Cross River State, Nigeria. J Appl Sci 2009; 12(3):8648–53.
34. Tomori O. Wild life rabies in Nigeria: experimental infection and transmission studies with the shrew (Crocidura sp.). Ann Trop Med Parasitol 1980; 74(2):151–6.
35. Lunney M, Jones A, Stiles E, Toews DW. Assessing humandog conflicts in Todos Santos, Guatamala: Bite incidences and public perception. Preven Vet Med 2011; 102(4):315–20.
36. Ahmed H, Chafe UM, Magaji AA, Abdul-Quadri A. Rabies and dog bite in children: a decade of experience in Sokoto Nigeria. Sokoto J Vet Sci 2000; 2(1):2–10.
37. Ly S, Buchy P, Heng NY, Ong S, Chhor N, Bourhy H, et al. “Rabies situation in Cambodia” PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2009; 3(9):1–8.
38. Omoke NI, Onyemaechi NOC. Incidence and pattern of dog bite injuries treated in the emergency room of a teaching hospital South East Nigeria. Afr J Med Health Sci 2018; 17(1):35–40.
39. Coleman PG, Dye C. Immunisation coverage required to prevent outbreaks of dog rabies. Vaccine 1996; 14(3):185–6.
40. Kaare M, Lembo T, Hampson K, Ernest E, Estes A, Mentel C, et al. Rabies control in rural Africa: evaluating strategies for effective domestic dog vaccination. Vaccine 2009; 27(1):152–60.
41. Abdulsalam AL, Oche MO, Awosan KJ, Alayande MO, Yunusa EU, Ango UM. Knowledge and practices regarding rabies prevention among dog owners in Sokoto, Nigeria. Int J Sci Studies 2018; 6(4):57–65.
42. Mshelbwala PP, Weese JS, Sanni-Adeniyi OA, Chakma S, Okeme SS, Mamun AA, et al. Rabies epidemiology, prevention and control in Nigeria: Scoping progress towards elimination. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2021; 15(8):e0009617. Available via https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd. 0009617
|